Divergence in Global Central Bank Monetary Policies
Advertisements
The landscape of global monetary policy is currently characterized by a remarkable divergence among the world's major central banks, driven by the complex interplay of inflation, economic performance, and geopolitical factorsIn the past month, a notable trend has emerged: a series of 25 basis point rate cuts have been implemented by several central banks, signaling a continuation of accommodative monetary strategiesThis includes the European Central Bank, the Bank of England, the Bank of Canada, the Reserve Bank of India, Bank Indonesia, and the South African Reserve Bank, all of whom have opted for an easing approachIn contrast, the U.SFederal Reserve and the Bank of Korea have held steady, while an unconventional path has been taken by the Bank of Japan and the Brazilian Central Bank, which are moving towards tightening monetary policy.
Amidst the complexities introduced by the "2.0 policy," central banks, including the Fed, face a future that is fraught with uncertainty
It is anticipated that these banks will continuously adapt their policies in response to evolving economic dataAlthough a significant reduction in interest rates might be off the table until at least 2025, the likelihood remains that the majority of central banks will continue toward an accommodating stanceAlthough the momentum for global rate cuts appears to be waning, it is far from being concluded.
In the United States, the Federal Reserve has opted to place a “pause” on interest rate cuts, as concerns surrounding inflation have somewhat alleviated and the labor market reflects resilienceOn January 30, the Fed communicated its first interest rate decision for 2025, deciding to maintain the federal funds rate within a range of 4.25% to 4.50%, following three consecutive rate cuts prior to this meetingDuring the subsequent press conference, Fed Chair Jerome Powell reiterated the commitment to a patient approach regarding policy adjustments, particularly in light of the cumulative 100 basis point reduction that occurred towards the latter part of the previous year
- 2025 Gold Surge
- Turning Point in Central European EV Industry
- Zebra Intelligence: Transforming Smart Cabins
- Rising U.S. National Debt Fuels Market Anxiety
- Can DeepSeek Revalue Chinese Tech Stocks?
He emphasized that while there is no pre-determined course for future rates, the Fed could consider cuts if labor market conditions were to weaken unexpectedly or if inflation were to decline sharply.
Recent economic data seems to support the Fed's decision to refrain from renewing rate cuts hastilyAs reported by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the U.S. economy is projected to grow at an annualized rate of 2.3% in the fourth quarter of 2024, slightly below the anticipated 2.6%, and down from 3.1% in the previous quarterAdditionally, the GDP growth rate for all of 2024 is estimated at 2.8%, a modest slowdown from the previous year’s 2.9%, yet still markedly robust compared to other advanced economies.
Furthermore, the preferred inflation measure of the Fed, the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index, also supports a wait-and-see approachThe Bureau of Economic Analysis reported that the core PCE price index rose by 0.3% in December 2024, echoing a year-over-year increase of 2.6%, aligning with forecasts
When excluding volatile food and energy prices, the core PCE saw a more tempered rise of 0.2% month over month, with an annual increase of 2.8%, also as anticipated.
Adding to this picture of stability in the U.S. labor market, the January report on payroll employment revealed that 143,000 jobs were added, which, while falling short of the expected 175,000, was tempered by an upward revision of 100,000 jobs for the prior two monthsThe unemployment rate dipped to 4.0%, better than the forecast of 4.1%, and the average hourly wage saw a year-over-year increase of 4.1%, exceeding the expected 3.8% growth.
Regarding the pathway of future monetary policy, the Fed has indicated it will carefully evaluate the latest data, the evolving economic landscape, and the balance of risks before considering changes to the federal funds rate rangeMoreover, it will continue to unwind its holdings of U.S
Treasury securities, government agency debt, and agency mortgage-backed securities, reinforcing its commitment to maximizing employment and returning inflation to its 2% target.
As the Fed adopts a more watchful stance, its monetary policy continues to be significantly influenced by inflation and employment metricsCurrent U.S. tariff policies present considerable uncertainties; while immediate immigration and energy policies could temporarily alleviate inflationary pressures, the potential for substantial tariffs against global trading partners in the future presents risks of reigniting inflation, thereby constraining the Fed's ability to lower rates.
Conversely, as central banks in major developed nations continue to engage in rate cuts, some, like the Bank of Japan, are at the forefront of tightening monetary conditions after emerging from a long period of deflationIn a historic move made on March 19 of the previous year, the BoJ decided to end its negative interest rate policy, raising rates from -0.1% to a range of 0 to 0.1%, and it subsequently eliminated its yield curve control initiative
On July 31, the bank raised the interest rate further to 0.25%, as it also announced plans to taper its government bond purchases over the next one to two yearsBy January 24, 2025, the BoJ raised rates to their highest point of the century, increasing the short-term interest rate by 25 basis points to 0.5%, marking the most significant single hike since February 2007.
The Bank of Japan defended its actions by citing the sustainability and stability of reaching its 2% inflation target, asserting that the current monetary policy adjustments were necessaryEven after these hikes, real interest rates are expected to remain significantly negative, suggesting that accommodative financial conditions will support economic activity for the time being.
Additionally, the BoJ recently updated its economic activity and price outlook report, raising its inflation forecast for fiscal years 2024 through 2026. It adjusted the core Consumer Price Index (CPI) projections for FY 2024 from 2.5% to 2.7%, FY 2025 from 1.9% to 2.4%, and FY 2026 from 1.9% to 2.0%. The bank noted a mild recovery in Japan's economy, despite persistent weakness in certain sectors, mentioning that core CPI is gradually converging upon the 2% target
With ongoing improvements in corporate profits and a growing sense of labor shortages, many businesses have expressed intentions to continue raising wages in their seasonal bargaining practices this year, maintaining the strong upward trend observed last year.
Looking forward, the BoJ indicated that future policy directions would rely heavily on developments in economic activity, price levels, and financial conditionsGiven that real interest rates are at significant lows, should the economic outlook remain optimistic as indicated in January’s report, the BoJ is likely to continue raising its policy interest rates and adjust the degree of monetary accommodation.
Japan's monetary policy appears firmly hawkish overall, suggesting that further increases in interest rates are possibleThe BoJ's Deputy Governor, Masayoshi Amamiya, has indicated a clear path towards raising rates, stating that Japan’s neutral rate is at least 1%, with expectations for short-term rates to reach this level by March 31, 2026. Meanwhile, Naoki Tamura, one of the more hawkish voices within the BoJ, has asserted the necessity for at least two more rate hikes before the end of Q1 next year to combat inflationary pressures.
Despite the prevailing narrative favoring rate cuts among many central banks, advanced economies are grappling with rising economic pressures and tapering inflation concerns
On February 6, the Bank of England announced a 25 basis point cut, bringing rates down to 4.5%, their lowest level since June 2023. This marked the third reduction in this rate-cut cycle as the BoE addresses sluggish economic growth.
The BoE has reduced its economic growth forecast for this year by half to 0.75%, reflecting a decline in business and consumer confidence alongside slower productivity growthFurthermore, the predictions for economic growth in 2026 and 2027 have only slightly increased from 1.25% to 1.5%.
Underlying inflation dynamics provide additional grounds for the BoE's decision to lower ratesAccording to the UK's Office for National Statistics, the CPI saw a year-on-year increase of 2.5% in December, slightly lower than both November and the economists' expectations of 2.6%. Core inflation, excluding volatile components like energy and food, fell from 3.5% in November to 3.2% in December
Notably, service sector inflation also dropped from 5.0% in November to 4.4%, the lowest since March 2022.
Nevertheless, the BoE has cautioned that inflation rates are expected to rise significantly later this year, predicting a peak of 3.7%, exceeding previous forecasts of 2.8%. The BoE does not expect inflation to return to the 2% target until the final quarter of 2027, which is six months later than initial projectionsWhile the potential for further cuts remains this year, the landscape of policy uncertainty continues to growBoE Governor Andrew Bailey has remarked that amidst ongoing declines in inflation, further rate cuts could indeed be possible, but emphasizes the need for careful assessment of both the magnitude and pace of these reductions in upcoming meetings.
In parallel to the UK's economic landscape, the Eurozone has faced relatively moderate inflationary pressures, enabling a more rapid descent towards rate cuts
On January 30, the European Central Bank opted for a 25 basis point reduction, marking the fifth cut since the easing cycle commenced in June 2024. Starting February 5, the deposit rate, primary refinancing rate, and marginal lending facility rate will be adjusted down to 2.75%, 2.90%, and 3.15%, respectively.
The ECB maintains a view that its current monetary stance remains restrictive, signaling an inclination towards further loosening in the futureMarket expectations point towards an additional 70 basis points in rate cuts this year, which would bring the policy rates to around 2%, entering a neutral rate range (estimated between 2% and 2.25%) as viewed by most analysts.
From an economic lens, the Eurozone posted zero growth in GDP for the fourth quarter of the previous year, below the anticipated 0.1% growth, with Germany, often considered the engine of the European economy, unexpectedly contracting by 0.2%. France, the second-largest economy in the Eurozone, also saw a GDP contraction of 0.1%, falling short of market expectations.
Looking ahead, the ECB has projected that its progress toward reducing inflation remains on track, with expectations that inflation will stabilize around the 2% mid-term target throughout the year