Challenges for Home Enterprises in Global Expansion

Advertisements

In recent years, the narrative of Chinese furniture companies has shifted dramatically from merely exporting products to crafting a globally recognized brand identity. To succeed in this venture, these companies must move beyond traditional business models, formulating distinct international strategies while embracing localization in their selected markets. The key to success lies in optimizing supply chains and mitigating trade barriers, ultimately enhancing their competitive edge in a crowded marketplace.

China's furniture industry has faced numerous obstacles domestically, including a slowdown in the real estate sector, weaker consumer demand, and intensifying competition. These hurdles have pushed many companies to seek new avenues for growth beyond their borders, leading to an increasingly bold approach to international expansion.

However, with the pursuit of internationalization come a myriad of challenges. Factors such as rising manufacturing costs, fluctuating tariffs, currency volatility, and varying cultural consumer habits pose significant hurdles. How can Chinese furniture enterprises navigate this intricate landscape of globalization? Can international growth truly serve as the secondary growth curve for the industry? There are compelling case studies and experiences from companies pioneering this path that lend valuable insights.

The early stages of international venture for many Chinese furniture businesses were primarily characterized by product exportation. One notable example is Man Wah Holdings, which became a significant player in international markets, establishing subsidiaries in crucial economic zones such as the US and the UK. Initially, Man Wah operated on an Original Design Manufacturer (ODM) model, producing functional sofas for overseas brands, which quickly solidified its standing in the international arena. Nevertheless, as global dynamics shifted, the company gradually reduced its dependency on the OEM model, pivoting towards enhancing its domestic market presence through its own branded retail, albeit still retaining a focus on some international ODM operations.

Prior to fiscal year 2018, Man Wah's overseas business represented the core of its market strategy. The company adeptly navigated downturns in the US and European real estate sectors due to an increase in its export penetration. This resilience in generating revenue, despite external challenges, was tested when raw material prices skyrocketed, leading to a significant profit drop of 51%. Gradually, Man Wah adapted by increasing the proportion of non-leather sofas in its offerings to buffer against these price volatilities.

As recovery took hold in the US housing market post-2018, Man Wah saw a restoration in its profit margins, posting over 70% compound annual growth for two consecutive years, and witnessing a meteoric rise in net profits. By 2015, the company reached a profit milestone of 1.75 billion HKD, and its stock price soared 16-fold from its 2011 lows.

By 2019, however, new challenges emerged as the company faced heightened risks from fluctuating raw material costs and a rapidly appreciating Chinese yuan, which resulted in significant currency exchange losses. Despite a 13.3% increase in sales within China, the additional 25% tariffs on US-bound products led to stagnated customer orders and a consequent 66% drop in share price.

Turning point came in fiscal year 2020, when the company's operational model experienced significant change, with domestic sales surpassing 50% of total revenue. This strategic shift established it as a successful exemplar of export-to-domestic conversion, resulting in a remarkable sevenfold stock price increase from its 2019 lows.

Yet the twin adjustment of the Chinese and US real estate markets in 2022 posed additional risks. Even as profits only fell by 15%, the share price suffered a staggering decline of up to 80% within a year, showcasing the volatile nature of market dynamics.

Valuations for companies like Man Wah have fluctuated wildly, with a historical low of 4.6x earnings in 2011 and a peak of 39x in 2021. Today, the price-to-earnings ratio hovers around 8x, revealing a pattern of significant valuation oscillation that often outstrips performance volatility and reflects broader macroeconomic conditions.

The “brand export” phase is evolving, as contemporary Chinese firms begin to emphasize building brand value and trust, recognizing the critical differentiation provided by strong branding and product value. The rapid growth of e-commerce has facilitated the growth of these brands on a global stage. Through platforms that enhance connectivity, Chinese-made furniture can swiftly reach international consumers, thus lowering sales costs and improving market responsiveness.

A compelling case study illustrating this trend is the emerging enterprise, Craft Home. While newer and more reliant on the US market, Craft Home also faced decline due to macroeconomic factors. In 2022, economic downturns in the US and a drop in consumer purchasing power caused their revenues to dip by 24%, and share prices fell by 43%. Fortunately, this downward trend showed signs of reversal in 2023 with market recovery.

By the third quarter of 2024, Craft Home's top ten clients were all American, primarily retail entities. Despite the competitive smart furniture market in the US, their focus on innovation has been consistently protected, solidifying their competitive advantage. Innovation goes beyond mere updates; it embodies a steadfast commitment to original design and seamless technology integration, supported by an internationally diverse team that enhances efficiency.

In their ongoing efforts to strengthen customer relationships, Craft Home actively participates in charitable initiatives and community engagement, enhancing their reputation and showcasing their commitment to values that resonate with consumers. Their branding efforts, represented by the MOTO brand which sponsors these community activities, foster recognition and loyalty among customers.

Looking ahead, as Craft Home deepens its brand promotion, they plan to engage in meaningful community engagements more actively, striving for synergy in quality products, strong teamwork, positive values, and brand image. The company aims to establish a solid, positive footprint in consumers’ minds.

By the close of the third quarter of 2024, Craft Home successfully constructed over 150 store-in-store setups across American retailers, signaling a firm commitment to building an international brand presence. By Q1 of 2025, their ambitious goal is to establish nearly 500 MOTO Gallery locations to amplify brand influence and drive sales growth.

As a contrast, another notable firm, Zhihou Technology, known for its popular internet home brands like SONGMICS and VASAGLE, has also demonstrated impressive growth. By Q3 of 2024, the company generated revenues of 5.7 billion RMB, marking a 38% increase. However, like many others, they have encountered challenges, facing rising shipping costs due to global supply chain issues that hinder profitability amid lower product value competition.

The experience of Chinese furniture companies in global markets reveals a narrative fraught with volatility yet ripe with growth opportunities. Market dynamics, rising manufacturing expenses, fluctuating international costs and tariffs, and cultural diversities demand agile adaptations. North American consumers generally prefer larger furniture pieces, while Southeast Asian buyers emphasize value for money, compelling businesses to tailor their product designs and marketing strategies accordingly.

Despite these challenges, the proactive efforts of Chinese furniture enterprises to expand globally remain resolute. Strategies focused on clear international objectives, localization in key markets, and optimization of supply chains are vital in enhancing competitiveness.

The global furniture market presents expansive growth prospects, leveraging China's manufacturing strengths in cost control, scalability, and supply chain integration. The rise of cross-border e-commerce has effectively solved the "last-mile" issues connecting products with consumers, creating closer connections between buyers and sellers. For instance, Zhihou Technology's emergence through Amazon channels allows them to directly engage with international customers, essentially transforming into a B2C e-commerce entity.

As global markets continue to open up and the influence of Chinese brands strengthens, the pathways for international expansion in the furniture sector are set to broaden. Globalization offers both significant opportunities and formidable challenges, marking an exciting yet complex future for Chinese furniture enterprises navigating this dynamic landscape.

Share this Article